Fire-Resistant Is Not Fireproof: What Really Decides Whether a Home Survives a Wildfire

No wall panel makes a home fireproof. What decides whether a house is still standing after a wildfire is mostly the detailing: the roof, the vents, the siding and the gaps between them.
That is the conclusion our Engineer of Record, Joe Pasma, PE, reaches in his article How SIPs Perform in Wildfire Zones. Joe has spent more than 40 years designing, testing and investigating structural insulated panels (SIPs). It matches what our architect sees on California wildfire projects, and it shapes how we design.
Embers do the damage
Joe's article attributes up to 90% of wildfire home losses to embers, not to the flame front. Embers can travel more than a mile ahead of a fire. They get into vents, roof valleys and unsealed joints, and they start the fire from the inside or the edges.
So the question to ask about a wildfire-zone home is where an ember can land and what it finds when it gets there.
Where SIPs help
A SIP wall is a solid foam core bonded between two structural skins. There are no open stud cavities for embers to collect in and no hidden air path inside the wall. There are fewer seams than in a framed wall, and the continuous insulation slows heat moving through it.
That is a real advantage. It is not a guarantee. A SIP home with a poorly detailed roof edge or an unrated vent has the same weak points as any other home.
What we specify
- A Class A roof covering, with metal as the first choice, and sealed ridges and eaves
- Ember-resistant vents and protected soffits
- Noncombustible siding: fiber cement, stucco or metal
- Metal fascia, and proper flashing wherever roof meets wall
- Every pipe and wire penetration sealed, with no exposed foam on the exterior
- A noncombustible zone in the first 5 feet around the building
A note on non-combustible panels
We are often asked whether a non-combustible panel skin, such as magnesium oxide board, removes the need for the rest. It does not. A skin that will not burn can still pass heat to the core behind it, so the assembly still needs its interior thermal barrier and its exterior cladding. Fire performance belongs to the whole assembly, tested and detailed as a system.
Why this matters for affordable housing
The families we build for cannot afford to lose a home, and most of this list costs little when it is designed in from the start. Good wildfire design is careful detailing, and careful detailing can be taught, repeated and delivered at scale.
Building in a wildfire zone and want to talk it through? Get in touch with J. L. Filbey & Sons.
Planning a resilient housing project?
Request a Proposal